Architecture Architecture Fails by Famous Architects: Oscar Niemeyer’s Personal Home

Architecture Architecture Fails by Famous Architects: Oscar Niemeyer’s Personal Home

Architecture Design is a tough racket, and all of us have screwed up at one point or another.

Architecture Don’t Get Locked Up Into Avoiding Lock-in
Architecture Trump Wants Immigrants to ‘Go Back.’ Native Americans Don’t.
Architecture Paola Antonelli of MoMA to give keynote speech at Dezeen Day

Architecture

Design is a tough racket, and all of us have screwed up at one point or another. But one thing that amazes me is when a screw-up gets all the way to the production stage. Mistakes I’ve made were always caught by a designer above me or an engineer developing the tooling drawings; but if you’re a big-name architect with no one above you, and/or the ill-advised freedom to ignore engineering input, errors can show up in the final product.Oscar Niemeyer is popularly considered one of the greatest architects of the 20th Century, and a man to whom Modernist architecture owes a great deal. Everyone from starry-eyed architecture students to art critics will wax poetic about his work. From the iconic UN Headquarters in New York to the dozens of standout structures designed for Brasilia, Niemeyer has more than secured his place in design history.United Nations Headquarters Cathedral of Brasília Palácio da Alvorada (Presidential residence) Memorial dos Povos Indígenas So you’d think that the house Niemeyer designed for himself in his home country of Brazil would be magnificent, Modernist, experimental. It isn’t, and in fact it’s rather muted. That’s all well and good–“muted” is subjective, after all–but at the very least, you’d expect it to be expertly designed as a functional home.Instead we find this fact about Casa Niemeyer, as reported by Arch Daily: “The porch drained rainwater into the veranda, leading to flooding on rainy days.” The flooding issue was a result of his design for the house which, according to AD quoting a 1961 issue of Habitat magazine, “demonstrated Niemeyer’s ‘low intimacy with conventional construction procedures.'”You may be thinking “Come on, is that really an architecture fail?” For an architect to not understand some very basic construction principles, I’d say yes. I understand if you disagree, but I think it’s a problem that a giant of Modernism did not understand…drainage. We’re not talking about the complicated science of how building materials will hold up after a century–which architects should know, of course–we’re talking about the very basic issue of rainwater and gravity. In my mind architecture should be permanent, given the resources that go into constructing a building, or at least long-lived. Designing a structure that naturally creates flooding seems like a mistake that ought have been made by a student and uncovered in a school crit.Are industrial designers any better? I can’t say so, when I know that hundreds of you are reading this on a phone with a cracked screen made out of fragile glass.

Rain Noe
Rain Noe is a writer and industrial designer based in New York City.

Local historic architecture can improve your design skills. Hit the bricks this weekend to jump start your education.

By Christopher Schwarz –

October 7

1 Comment

Considering species beyond humans in architecture and urban planning

By John P. Kazior –

September 10

1 Comment

Developed in collaboration with Skyline Design, their range of glass panels debuted at NeoCon and won Silver in the Architectural and Decorative Glass category

By Alexandra Alexa –

June 19

To save their dwindling population, Terreform ONE is creating “a vertical meadow” for butterflies right in the heart of downtown Manhattan

By Alexandra Alexa –

June 10

1 Comment

WHY DID I NOT KNOW ABOUT THIS SOONER

By Rain Noe –

November 1

1 Comment

The finest of industrial design

By Rain Noe –

November 1

4 Comments

Magician Zach King’s magical chairs

By Rain Noe –

November 1

3 Comments

Because no one wants to see a criminal mastermind operating out of a split-level ranch

By Rain Noe –

November 1

1 Comment

A passion for product and a strong interest in UX design are what you need to succeed

By Coroflot Jobs –

November 1

Instead of teaching kids to buy and consume, Loot prefers they borrow and learn to create

By Rain Noe –

November 1

The most notable campaigns of the week

By Core Jr –

October 31

An example: “Elementary school phys-ed teacher who is not good at exercise”

By Rain Noe –

October 31

An example: “Fan who tries to make heart symbol with pop idol, but she won’t do it”

By Rain Noe –

October 31

by What The Block for Copenhagen Institute of Interaction Design

By Core77 Design Awards –

October 31

An example: “Person who must photograph food dishes from directly above”

By Rain Noe –

October 31

An example: “Unhelpful person who shows up at barbecue to partake, but offers no assistance”

By Rain Noe –

October 31

An example: “Actress in a traffic safety video pretending she’s just caused an accident”

By Rain Noe –

October 31

If you’re interested in working as a design educator or as a designer in an academic setting, now is a good time to make your move

By Coroflot Jobs –

October 31

1 Comment

Is it even possible to use technology more in order to use it less?

By Rain Noe –

October 30

Core77’s Design Directory

Read More

COMMENTS

WORDPRESS: 0
DISQUS: 0